Stigma v stats: Is South American travel really as dangerous as we think?

Many Australians skip South America because they think it's unsafe, but crime varies sharply between countries and cities, and travellers who have been say the reputation is overblown.

If you ask a casual Australian traveller why they haven’t visited South America, the answer usually comes fast: “it’s dangerous”. The reality is more nuanced. Crime risks differ sharply between countries and cities, and travellers who have actually made the trip often describe a very different continent.

It’s important to remember that South America is a huge continent with different climates, cultures and, yes, degrees of safety. For example, London, one of Europe’s major cities and Montevideo, one of South America’s, sit at almost the same crime index, yet nobody warns you off London.  The risk is not the same everywhere. According to a global study on homicide by the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Argentina recorded 4.3 homicides per 100 000 people in 2022, compared with 11.2 in Uruguay, while Brazil’s rate was 21.3 in 2021.

Meanwhile, Smartraveller advises Australians to exercise a high degree of caution in Columbia and Peru, because of the threat of violent crime. For Peru it is because of a state of emergency in Lima and Callao, whereas for Columbia it is because of criminals using incapacitating drugs on victims, becoming vulnerable to robbery and sexual assault.

But just because some parts of the continent can be dangerous, should it stop you visiting?

Lucas Brancatisano doesn’t think so. He runs “Aussies In”, a network of WhatsApp travel groups, a support system for Australians and New Zealanders travelling to the more underexplored destinations. It is specifically for regions like South America where he wants to get more people to go.

Brancatisano spent 10 months backpacking in South America before starting Aussies In.

“It’s probably one of the most enchanting, special places to visit on earth,” he tells upstart.

“The idea was born in Latin America when I was there, I just thought, less than Europe, there’s fundamentally just way less information available.”

The gap the resource covers is practical basics such as finding buses, choosing routes and building confidence and comfort— a big reason Aussies In was created. Brancatisano says it is unfortunate that people miss out on the beauty of the area because of the stigma.

“To nail down a few cities or countries and say their entire people are like that …  you’re fundamentally missing out on going and experiencing an amazing place.”

However, like most major cities across the world, people do need to be wary of their personal safety at times. Jorge Severich, a tour guide from G Adventures , leads trips in Bolivia, Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil. He explains that certain precautions are important when travelling in South America. But these are just the normal precautions and practices people should take at night in any big city.

“Beyond 10pm, the streets run out of police officers and drunk people are around, so it’s better to avoid walking around the streets,” he tells upstart.

“As long as you respect the rules of citizenship security, there is nothing to worry about.”

Brancatisano reminds would-be travellers that having a bad experience could happen anywhere.

“When you’re travelling things happen,” he says. “You can get robbed in Italy. You can get robbed in Rome. It’s almost part of the experience.”

“If it happens, you can’t just say that it’s a dangerous country.”

Brancatisano has only heard positive things from Aussies In members who explored South America.

“People go over expecting maybe a seven out of 10, like ‘I don’t know what’s going to happen, I’ll probably get robbed a few times’,” he says.

“But literally everyone I’ve spoken to has said, ‘I wish I could have spent more time there’.”

The more people visit for themselves and see the beauty the continent has to offer, the more the stigma will be challenged. Brancatisano encourages people to get their information from people who have actually experienced South America.

“I’m always super sceptical when I hear about a place from a news source or a publication, because I’m always like ‘you guys haven’t been there, and you literally don’t even know what you’re talking about’,” he says.

Familiarity is usually a big factor for people when travelling, Brancatisano says. For many Australians, their first overseas trip is often to Bali Indonesia or places in Europe, Indonesia was the most popular overseas destination for Australians in 2024-24, with 14.2 per cent of all overseas trips. They feature heavily on Australian news and social media for the same reasons. South America doesn’t have that same exposure or inherited familiarity.

“If they’ve never been or they don’t know anyone that’s been, they just assume it’s scary,” Brancatisano says.

Another issue is that media coverage tends to lump South American countries and cities together, treating the entire continent as a single risk category. For example, Travel Binger, an online travel publication, described Venezuela, Columbia, Ecuador, Brazil and Rio De Janeiro as five cities/countries tourists were “quietly avoiding”. However, further down the same article, they do point out that Montevideo, Santiago and Buenos Aires rank among the safest cities in the continent and that “none of this means South America is off limits”.

Both Brancatisano and Severich say that listening to people who have never been or leaning into a stigma built on a few bad stories, should not deter you from ticking off bucket list destinations. Basic precautions, rather than avoiding the trip is the answer.

“There has to be a point where you decide who you’re going to listen to,” Brancatisano says. “What should you make decisions based on?”

“Other people telling you about a place, or you going and finding out for yourself?”


Article: Michael Gerace is a third-year Bachelor of Media and Communications student at La Trobe University. You can follow him on X @MichaelGerace18

Cover photo: Rio de Janeiro taken by author

Related Articles

Melbourne’s best cheap eats

From $4 pasta to a $15 Vietnamese pho, Melbourne offers affordable and high-quality meals to satisfy everyone’s taste.

More than a trend: The rise of modest fashion

Mainstream fashion is making it easier for young hijabi women to find clothing that offers modesty, comfort and style, as loose and oversized trends move from niche markets into the mainstream.

Editor's Picks